Skip to Content

Why are schools banning The Giver?

The Giver has been a controversial book in the public education system for several reasons. It has been banned in some schools because it contains mature themes including death, euthanasia, and suicide.

This can be a difficult topic to discuss and parents may feel uncomfortable with their children reading about these topics. Additionally, the book contains graphic depictions of violence and lacks any positive messages that are typically found in children’s literature.

The book is also seen as having an ambiguous ending that does not clearly provide a moral resolution. Therefore, some schools have made the decision to ban The Giver due to the mature themes and lack of a positive message in the book.

Why is The Giver being banned?

The Giver is a 1994 young-adult novel by Nobel Prize-winning author Lois Lowry. Despite its immense popularity, it is one of the most disputed books in schools and libraries around the world. Many parents and educators have expressed concerns over The Giver’s illustrations of a dark, dystopian world with a pro-euthanasia message.

At the heart of the controversy is the novel’s plot. Set in the future, the story follows protagonist Jonas in his journey to challenge the oppressive rules of his society. Starting with the Assignment Ceremony, each person’s place in the world is determined from birth.

Jonas is assigned the job of Receiver of Memory, which allows him to remember all of Earth’s past in order to make better decisions for the future. Through their connection, he learns of the government’s controversial policy of euthanizing select citizens, including the elderly and the disabled, creating a society without pain or suffering.

Outraged by this unjust practice, Jonas works to end euthanasia and to bring colors of different hues back to his society. But since the novel contains graphic and disturbing images, some parents have argued that readers, especially young ones, can be exposed to morally questionable themes.

Others have said that the book promotes euthanasia and encourages children to think critically about real-world issues, making it socially inappropriate.

The Giver continues to be one of the most banned books throughout the world. It is seen as a challenge to authority and a reminder to break free from a restrictive society. While the book’s protagonist is the figure of rebellion and social reform, many parents fear the book’s pro-euthanasia message or disagree with its dark illustrations.

These potential risks, combined with readers’ possible disconnect from the ethical gravity of the disturbing message, can lead to dangerous consequences.

How many times was The Giver banned?

The Giver has been banned numerous times since its initial publication in 1994. According to the American Library Association, it was one of the most challenged books of the 1990s and early 2000s. Common reasons cited for its banning include claims that it contains offensive language, sexual scenes, and violence, as well as its religiously “depressing” themes.

The Giver has been banned in school districts in California, Florida, Michigan, Texas, and Wisconsin in the United States, as well as in school districts in Canada, Ireland, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom, among others.

Additionally, the book has been removed from public libraries, including public libraries in Chicago, Colorado Springs, and Orange, California.

Despite its frequent banning, The Giver has also been lauded for its themes of acceptance and tolerance, as well as its ability to stimulate meaningful classroom conversations. For example, the American Library Association named it one of the ten most influential books of the past twenty years, while Forbes magazine called it “one of the most important books of the last twenty years.”

What are the most banned books?

The most frequently banned books vary depending on the location and specific time period, but some of the most commonly banned books across time include books such as: The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain, which has been banned for its language and perceived racism; The Catcher in the Rye by J.D.

Salinger, which has been banned for its explicit language and portrayal of sexuality and violence; 1984 by George Orwell, which has been banned for its negative portrayal of government; The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, which has been banned for its mature content; The Lord of the Flies by William Golding, which has been banned for its themes of savagery and fear; and Animal Farm by George Orwell, which has been banned for its communist themes.

Other frequently banned books include To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, The Giver by Lois Lowry, Brave New World by Aldous Huxley, and Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury.

What are ethical issues in The Giver?

One of the main ethical issues in The Giver revolves around the concept of sameness: every aspect of life in the community is predetermined, leaving no room for individuality or personal choice. This means that many people are unable to experience the joys and failures of life on their own terms, and instead must follow what the community dictates.

Another ethical issue in The Giver is the idea of using the elderly as resources. The elderly are expected to hold the memories of the past, but they are not given a meaningful role in the community.

This can be dangerous, as it can lead to the elderly feeling unvalued and unimportant, which could lead to depression and other psychological issues.

A third ethical issue in The Giver is the way in which the government enforces its rules and restrictions. People are not allowed to question the government or its decisions, and dissenters are punished.

This lack of freedom leaves citizens feeling powerless and unable to make changes in their own lives.

Finally, the practice of infanticide is an ethical issue in The Giver. According to the government, any baby born with physical or mental disabilities must be euthanized. This raises questions about whether it is ethical to deny someone the chance to experience life, regardless of their condition.

Overall, The Giver addresses several ethical issues that take away from the humanity and free will of its citizens. These ethical issues highlight the need for individuals to be empowered to make decisions and lead lives that allow them to experience the full breadth of life.

Why is The Giver so controversial?

The Giver is a 1993 young adult novel by Lois Lowry which has become one of the most frequently challenged and banned books due to its controversial subject matter. In the book, Lowry presents a utopian society where order and sameness have been achieved by replacing feelings, memories, and pain with conformity.

The Giver follows protagonist Jonas, who is assigned the role of Receiver of Memory, allowing him to experience the world before it was rid of emotion and individuality for the first time.

The Giver has been highly controversial for its themes of totalitarianism, censorship, and the loss of individuality. Critics have accused the book of promoting a dystopian view of society and of subtly advocating communism or fascism.

Others have argued that its approach to difficult topics such as euthanasia and government control can be seen as an endorsement of such practices.

More generally, The Giver has also been controversial due to its lack of explicit religious messages and its focus on an authoritarian society. The fact that Lowry allows the reader to form his or her own opinion on the rules of the utopian society, rather than guiding them to a particular choice or moral conclusion, has also been a source of contention.

The lack of didacticism, however, is precisely what has made The Giver one of the most enduring and engaging works of young adult literature.

Why is color removed from The Giver?

The color was removed from The Giver in order to create a stark contrast between the life of Jonas and his world, one that is devoid of color and joy. It is the removal of something tangible and tangible that allows readers to feel Jonas’s pain, as he figures out how he can bring color back to the world of the Giver.

The removal of color also serves to emphasize how Jonas’s life is one of uniformity and dullness– his world is an emotionless, dull place with no depth or true beauty. This also serves to highlight the importance of memories– and how the memories from the Giver, the memories with color and vibrancy, are necessary in order to bring life and passion back to their society.

By taking away color, Lowry is showing just how limited and rigid the life of Jonas really is, and how memories can provide the joy and color that is lost in their society.

Is the book The Giver banned in US?

No, the book The Giver is not currently banned in the United States. The Giver is a 1993 young adult novel by Lois Lowry that has been widely acclaimed in the literary world, winning the 1994 Newbery Medal, one of the most prestigious awards offered in children’s literature.

The novel has remained popular since its initial release, leading to the 2014 film adaptation starring Jeff Bridges and Meryl Streep. The book has occasionally been challenged and restricted in some states, but it has not been banned anywhere in the United States.

Challenges have focused primarily on the themes of euthanasia, suicide, and abortion contained within the story. The American Library Association has reported numerous attempts to have the book removed from school or public library shelves, but none of these efforts have been successful.

To date, The Giver remains widely distributed and appreciated in both book and movie formats in the United States.

Where was The Giver banned or challenged?

The Giver by Lois Lowry has frequently been banned or challenged in classrooms and libraries around the United States since its publication in 1993. The book’s dark themes, such as euthanasia, death, family dysfunction, suicide, and its lack of a traditional happy ending make it a target for censorship and debate.

According to the American Library Association, the novel has faced censorship in states such as Arkansas, Michigan, Minnesota, New Mexico, and Texas. Additionally, the book has faced opposition in locations such as Huron, South Dakota; Etobicoke, Ontario; and St. Augustine, Florida.

Aside from simply being banned from inclusion in school reading lists or library shelves, The Giver has also faced various other forms of censorship. In the years following the publication of The Giver, the book has been challenged in various schools throughout the United States.

In some cases, parents even went so far as to demand that certain chapters of the book be removed from school curricula.

In 2001, The Giver was included in a list of potentially “dangerous books” by the Marshall, Texas public library. In this case, the book was included based on a complaint filed by a parental group who claimed that The Giver was “not part of a balanced curriculum”.

The Giver is also widely considered to often be the center of censorship debates primarily due to its dark undertones. Such examples of censors stating concerns regarding this novel are not limited to its language, adult topics and dysfunctional family dynamics, but more explicitly its attack on religion, its portrayal of drugs and alcohol use and its lack of traditional values.

In conclusion, The Giver by Lois Lowry has faced various forms of censorship and challenges since its publication in 1993. The novel has faced opposition in locations such as Arkansas, Michigan, Minnesota, New Mexico, Texas, Huron, South Dakota, Etobicoke, Ontario, St. Augustine, Florida, and Marshall, Texas.

The Giver has also been subject to challenges and parental complaints about the book’s dark themes, language, adult topics, lack of traditional values, and attack on religion.

Why is The Giver prohibited from asking to be released?

The Giver is prohibited from asking to be released from their role as the Receiver of Memory because they are held responsible for transmitting the memories of the past to the people in the community.

This role is essential for the sustainability of the community and is a vital position for the society to continue in its current form. Without the Giver, individuals would not be able to rely on the memories from traditionally passed down from older generations, resulting in losing the wisdom that has been accumulated throughout human evolution.

Additionally, it is likely that there would be chaos in the community as individuals are no longer able to understand the importance of making decisions through the lens of a collective understanding and past experiences.

The Giver is the keeper of this accumulated wisdom, which can not be replaced or redistributed without them. Therefore, it is essential that they do not ask to be released, or else the society as they know it will cease to exist.

What is inappropriate about The Giver?

The Giver is a popular young adult novel by author Lois Lowry, which was published in 1993 and has since been made into a movie, but there is quite a bit of content in the book and film that may be considered inappropriate for some viewers – particularly younger audiences.

Examples of inappropriate material in the book and film include scenes involving violence, death, and suicide, as well as a romance between a twelve- year-old boy and a girl who looks to be in her teens or early twenties.

Additionally, the movie features several suggestive scenes and dialogue, and some viewers may find the depictions of loneliness, isolation, and euthanasia distressing and inappropriate. Ultimately, viewers may want to exercise caution when determining whether The Giver is appropriate for their own children or for other young viewers.

Why do people not like The Giver?

Many people don’t like The Giver because they find the subject matter depressing and depressing. The novel tells the story of a futuristic, utopian society in which the elderly have the responsibility to serve as “Giver”, a holder of all collective memories, wisdom and experience.

This society is highly structured and regimented, with its population visualized as grey and indistinguishable. Furthermore, the citizens of the society have limited access to knowledge and freedom of choice, with most decisions made for them by the governing body.

There is a lack of color in the society, creating an atmosphere of conformity and sameness. People who don’t like The Giver find the concept of a regimented, conformist society and the lack of freedom to make choices emotionally overwhelming and undesirable.

Additionally, certain scenes featured in the novel, such as when a child is “released” from the community, can be incredibly heartbreaking and haunting to those who don’t appreciate the themes of the book.

Overall, many people don’t like The Giver because it paints too bleak a picture of a seemingly perfect society.

What grade level is The Giver appropriate for?

The Giver is an award-winning young adult novel written by Lois Lowry. It is an excellent read for students in grades 5-8 due to its captivating story and thoughtful themes. The Giver is a dystopian novel that challenges readers to think critically about their own world over the course of its plot.

The Giver can be somewhat dark in some passages, but is still appropriate for its targeted age range.

Although targeted for 5th-8th grade readers, it has wide appeal for readers across a variety of age ranges. Many teenagers and adults also enjoy the novel for its gripping plotline and thought-provoking themes.

The Giver has won numerous awards, including the Newbery Medal, being named an ALA Notable Children’s Book, and being nominated for the 2010 NAACP Image Award. All these awards demonstrate that The Giver is a captivating story with writing of the highest quality.

In summary, The Giver is considered appropriate for readers in grades 5-8. With its engaging plot, thematically-rich content, and award-winning status, The Giver is sure to provide a stimulating and enjoyable read for any age.

Is Jonas allowed to lie in The Giver?

No, Jonas is not allowed to lie in The Giver, at least not in the same way that most people understand lying. In the book, lying isn’t part of the community that Jonas lives in, and the concept of lying isn’t even understood.

Instead, lying is referred to as “blurring the truth”. Blurring the truth is a way of omitting certain details or distorting facts in order to achieve a goal. This is a common practice in the community, and it is seen as acceptable as long as it doesn’t result in harm or danger to others.

Therefore, rather than actually lying, which is not allowed, Jonas is allowed to blur the truth if it will result in benefiting himself or his community.

Why is the movie The Giver in black and white?

The movie The Giver is in black and white to emphasize the sterile and cold environment in which the story takes place. The colorless world in which the Giver lives is meant to represent a lack of emotion and individuality, which in turn makes the characters’ eventual journey of personal growth more impactful.

By using black and white, the filmmakers are able to create a stark contrast between the dullness of the Giver’s world and the vibrant colors of the new world that is discovered. In addition to this, the lack of color helps to further emphasize the rigid and oppressive nature of the Giver’s world, adding to the overall themes of the movie.

Through this visual choices, the filmmakers of The Giver are able to reinforce key themes of the film, conveying them more effectively to the viewer.