Skip to Content

Why is hoarding so difficult to treat?

Hoarding disorder is a complex mental health condition that is notoriously difficult to treat due to its many facets and influences. As a result, Hoarding is associated with tremendous physical, emotional, social, economic and legal burdens.

Sufferers of hoarding may have difficulty throwing away or discarding possessions. This difficulty is compounded by situations such as an accumulation of clutter and mess, poor decision making, perfectionism, difficulty regulating emotions and thoughts, memories attached to possessions, difficulty categorizing and organizing, and avoidance of addressing the problem.

Moreover, hoarding is often intertwined with other mental health issues such as depression and anxiety, which can make the treatment process more challenging. Individuals may be reluctant to address their hoarding behavior and are often unaware of the ways in which it has a negative impact on their lives and the lives of their loved ones.

The task of organizing and decluttering belongings can be overwhelming and can easily stir up strong, distressing emotions.

Due to its complexity, treatment for hoarding disorder is typically best managed with a team of professionals, including psychiatrists, psychologists, and social workers. Cognitive-behavioral therapy is often used and focuses on helping individuals become aware of the beliefs, thoughts and behaviors related to hoarding, and developing helpful strategies and skills to manage these beliefs, thoughts and behaviors.

Additionally, environmental modifications, including decluttering and organizing, as well as pharmacological treatments prescribed by a psychiatrist, may also be helpful and should be considered.

What is the root cause of hoarding disorder?

The exact root cause of hoarding disorder is not yet known. Several factors are believed to contribute to a person’s risk for developing hoarding disorder, including early life experiences, genetics, and psychological and social factors.

Early life experiences, such as neglectful or abusive parenting, may contribute to a person’s risk of developing the disorder. Difficulties with family dynamics, such as relationships with siblings, or learning that object attachment is a way to cope with powerful emotions, may also increase someone’s risk.

For some people, hoarding disorder may have a genetic component. Family members may have a common pattern of collecting items or have similar habits of hoarding. Based on twin studies, hoarding is 55-62% heritable, indicating a possible genetic link.

Other psychosocial and environmental factors may also influence the development of hoarding disorder. People with low self-esteem, difficulty controlling impulses, or difficulty making decisions may be more likely to develop the disorder.

Moreover, those who have experienced a traumatic event can find comfort in the act of collecting, leading to hoarding behavior overall. For some, hoarding is a reaction to a major life event, such as death, divorce, or unemployment.

The underlying risk factors that contribute to hoarding disorder are numerous and complex, making it difficult to pinpoint the exact underlying cause. Treatment for hoarding disorder often focuses on addressing the symptoms and working to manage the underlying causes in combination.

What kind of trauma causes hoarding?

Hoarding is a mental health disorder characterized by a tendency to save and accumulate items, often to the point of filling living spaces and creating chaotic and cluttered environments. Hoarding is not simply the result of clutter or difficulty getting rid of items, it is a serious mental illness that can be caused by a variety of factors.

Trauma can be a contributing factor to hoarding. This is often experienced in intensity, meaning that the more severe the trauma, the more likely someone is to develop hoarding disorder. Traumatic events such as the death of a loved one, a natural disaster, war, abuse, abandonment, or any other extremely distressing event can lead to an increase in hoarding behaviors.

When a person is exposed to a traumatic event, their natural defenses for coping with stress become ineffective, leading to extreme distress. In order to cope with this distress, some people may start accumulating items as a way of self-soothing and gaining a sense of safety and control.

Hoarding can also be a result of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

People who hoard often suffer in silence due to shame, embarrassment and fear. It is important to recognize that hoarding is a serious mental health condition with possible consequences on the quality of life of both the hoarder themselves, and their family and friends.

If someone is struggling with hoarding behaviors, it is important to seek professional help in order to develop an effective treatment plan.

What mental illness causes hoarding?

Hoarding is a pattern of behavior that is associated with a number of mental health conditions, most notably Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD), Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD), Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), Substance Abuse Disorders, Bipolar Disorder, and, sometimes, Schizophrenia.

While the OCD-associated form of hoarding is the most commonly cited subtype, hoarding can develop in the context of any of these disorders.

Individuals with OCD often experience recurrent thoughts of worry, fear, or doubt that drive specific compulsions to organize, acquire, or save an excessive number of possessions. Inattention and executive functioning may be affected in individuals with ADHD, leading to overly sentimental attachment toward possessions.

GAD can lead to an inability to discard objects of meaning, which can contribute to hoarding behavior. People with bipolar disorder may be prone to impulsivity in the form of acquiring more items than needed, which is a factor in the development of hoarding.

Substance Abuse Disorders can also result in issues with discarding unnecessary items. Lastly, those with Schizophrenia may experience delusions that inspire a need to keep otherwise meaningless items.

In any of these cases, the underlying symptoms often lead to significant distress for the individual and their family, so treatment is important.

Hoarding can be a difficult issue to address and manage, and should be addressed through the help of a licensed mental health practitioner or specialist. Treatment of hoarding can involve any combination of medication, cognitive behavioral therapy, motivational interviewing, and other forms of talk therapy.

It is important to address the underlying mental health issues that may be contributing to hoarding, and seek the proper treatments these conditions require.

What are the personality traits of a hoarder?

Hoarders tend to be rigid and controlling, with an intense need to possess objects. They often focus on objects that represent security or are associated with happy childhood memories. Hoarders may have experienced trauma as a child, which has caused them to have a deep-rooted emotional attachment to objects.

These individuals often have difficulty making decisions and struggle with hard choices. They tend to display perfectionist tendencies and have difficulty managing time and tasks. Some hoarders experience extreme anxiety and fear of loss when getting rid of objects.

They may struggle with social isolation, depression and difficulty adjusting to change. They may also tend to be stubborn and resist the attempts of others to help them. Hoarders may also have low self-esteem and lack of assertiveness, often giving into their guilt and anxiety.

Hoarding can have a significant impact on an individual’s physical and mental health, relationships, and overall quality of life.

Do hoarders lack empathy?

Hoarding has long been thought of as a problem of compulsive consumption based on the inability to part with possessions, often on a large and unreasonable scale. However, the mental health disorder of Hoarding Disorder (HD) goes well beyond the inability to discard possession and suggests a deep emotional connection to material objects.

Generally, it is assumed that people with HD lack empathy for others.

The evidence for this is largely anecdotal, based on observations of the way that people with HD deal with others. People with severe hoarding behavior may not appear to understand the impact their possessions have on other people in their environment, such as family members or roommates.

Similarly, they may not appear to be aware of their own behavior and its negative implications for those around them, such as disregarding another individual’s time or neglecting to provide a safe living environment for those living in the same space.

Viewing HD as the result of an inability to empathize or understand the feelings of others provides an explanation for why people with HD struggle to remove possessions, as it suggests they may be invested in protecting them due to an attitude of ‘emotional attachment’.

It also explains why people with HD may be resistant to addressing the problem and appearing uncooperative when encouraged by family or professional organizers.

While the evidence strongly suggests that people with HD may lack empathy, research has been inconclusive. Some studies have indicated that people with HD may have difficulty with interpersonal relationships, which could suggest an impairment in empathy.

However, research has generally been limited to self-report questionnaires and case studies, which means that further research is necessary to gain a complete understanding of HD in relation to empathy.

Ultimately, it appears that the answer remains inconclusive and further research is needed to fully understand this connection.

Does hoarding get worse with age?

The answer to this question is somewhat complicated. In some cases, hoarding can worsen with age. In people who already have a hoarding disorder, their symptoms may become more severe over time due to the ongoing stressors of living with the disorder.

There are also several mental and physical factors that can contribute to the worsening of symptoms for some individuals with hoarding disorder. For example, older adults may report increased difficulty making decisions and organizing their belongings, which can create further levels of clutter and disorganization.

Cognitive decline due to aging can also make it harder for individuals with hoarding disorder to recognize the need for de-cluttering and organize their possessions.

However, data from research studies indicates that hoarding does not necessarily get worse with age for everyone. Some older adults with hoarding disorder remain relatively stable, while others actually show some improvement.

Additionally, research indicates that people can still successfully transition to new ways of managing their possessions, even in late life.

Because specific factors determine how the symptoms of hoarding disorder manifest and change throughout a person’s life, it’s important to seek a qualified professional to evaluate what type of interventions might be beneficial.

A mental health professional can evaluate the individual’s situation and create a comprehensive treatment plan to reduce the severity of hoarding disorder.

How do you tell a hoarder they have a problem?

If you suspect a loved one is a hoarder, it’s important to approach the situation in a respectful, kind manner. It’s also helpful to do your research about hoarding disorder before you have a conversation with your loved one.

Here are some tips to help you talk to a hoarder:

1. Start by expressing your concern in a sensitive, non-judgmental way.

2. Explain to your loved one that you fear their hoarding is keeping them from living a life they’re happy with, and that it’s causing a strain on their family relationships.

3. Discuss the physical and emotional risks associated with hoarding, such as potential injury due to tripping on clutter, the possibility of a fire due to the accumulation of combustibles and the mental worry about their living environment.

4. Point out specific problem areas of the home that you have noticed, and explain how the clutter is blocking important pathways or putting them at risk for injury.

5. Ask your loved one to create a plan to reduce the clutter, such as setting incremental goals, seeking professional help from a hoarding specialist, or consulting with a mental health professional.

6. Encourage your loved one to embark on a decluttering journey by offering to help or to find resources in your community, such as support groups or disposal services.

It’s important to be mindful that a hoarding disorder can be very personal and sensitive. While the conversation may not be easy, it could potentially provide your loved one with the help they need to make changes in their life.

Is hoarding a form of dementia?

No, hoarding is not a form of dementia. It is a form of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). Hoarding is characterized by a person having an intense attachment to their belongings, leading them to gather and save items that may be of no real value.

People with hoarding disorder often have difficulty discarding items, leading to clutter in the home, on the job, and other places.

Hoarding behavior can interfere with day-to-day activities, such as taking a shower or sleeping. It can also have an emotional impact, leading to feelings of anxiety, embarrassment, and shame. Hoarding has been recognized as an distinct mental health disorder since 2013 when it was included in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5).

Dementia, on the other hand, is a decline in mental ability that is severe enough to interfere with a person’s ability to perform everyday activities, including memory, communication, understanding, judgment, and problem solving.

It is caused by physical changes in the brain. Symptoms can progress over time, leading to memory loss, impaired behavior, and difficulty completing everyday tasks.

Though hoarding and dementia share some similarities, they are entirely different disorders. People suffering from hoarding disorder can benefit from cognitive behavioral therapy and/or medications, while dementia is a medical condition that must be treated by a medical professional such as a neurologist.

How do you stop a hoarding behavior?

Stopping a hoarding behavior is not an easy process and can take time and patience. Hoarding can cause distress and can be a sign of underlying psychological issues, so it is important to get a professional opinion and develop a customized plan to manage the issue.

The first step in stopping a hoarding behavior is to identify and address any underlying issues, such as depression, anxiety, or OCD. Working with a therapist can help to get to the root of the problem and find ways to manage the underlying issues.

The next step is to create a plan for addressing the hoarding behavior. This might include: creating a clutter-free home environment by establishing limits on how many possessions can be kept; setting up a system for organizing items; learning how to make decisions about what to keep and what to get rid of; and working on challenges like letting go of sentimental items.

Finally, it’s important to set up a maintenance plan for keeping the hoarding behavior in check. This includes regular cleanups, using visual reminders to help with organization, and creating systems that help to prioritize the tasks that need to be done so that the living space remains clutter free.

Building healthy habits and routines into everyday life can also help manage the hoarding behavior and create a healthier environment.

Is it even possible to cure hoarding?

Although it may be difficult, it is possible to cure hoarding. Treatment for hoarding disorder is primarily psychological, and includes cognitive behavioural therapy, which can help a person to identify and challenge the thoughts and beliefs which are causing their hoarding behaviour, and train them how to manage their emotions and how to make decisions about what to keep and what to discard.

Medications can also be used to help manage the anxiety and depression which often accompany hoarding disorder. In addition, family members can often play a role in helping the person to reduce their hoarding behaviour, as well as helping them to find better ways to manage their possessions.

Finally, other treatments such as hoarding-specific support groups and professional decluttering and organisation services can also be beneficial. With a combination of these treatments, it is possible for individuals to make significant progress towards reducing their hoarding behaviour.

Can hoarders stop hoarding?

Yes, hoarders can stop hoarding. It will take a lot of work and dedication, however. Hoarding is usually a symptom of an underlying mental health issue, such as Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) or an anxiety disorder.

In order to stop hoarding, a hoarder must address the mental health issue and make changes to their lifestyle. This can include seeking professional help from a mental health counselor or therapist, learning to manage anxiety, and developing healthy coping skills for stress and difficulty.

Practicing self-awareness can also be helpful, such as recognizing triggers or moments when hoarding impulses may arise, and talking to a trusted friend or family member. Finally, establishing a regular cleaning and decluttering routine can also be beneficial, such as setting aside a specific amount of time a day or week to clean and discard any items that are clutter or no longer serve a purpose.

It may take some time and hard work, but with commitment and support, hoarders can stop hoarding.

Are all hoarders mentally ill?

No, not all hoarders are mentally ill. While research has suggested a link between hoarding disorder and mental illness, it does not mean that all hoarders have a mental illness. Hoarding disorder can be a complex condition that manifests itself differently in different individuals.

It is estimated that about 2-5% of the population suffers from hoarding disorder, but only a small percentage of these people may be diagnosed with a mental illness.

Research has suggested that certain subtypes of hoarders do tend to suffer from a mental illness such as anxiety, depression, or obsessive-compulsive disorder. It is important to remember, however, that even in these cases it might not be the mental illness that is causing the hoarding behavior.

In many cases, the mental illness may be the result of the extreme distress associated with living in a home filled with clutter and disorganization.

If you suspect that you or someone you know may be suffering from hoarding disorder, it is important to seek help in order to get the proper diagnosis and treatment. A mental health professional can help assess the severity of the condition and determine if any mental illness is present or contributing to the problem.

Treatment for hoarding disorder can involve medication, therapy, education, and lifestyle changes that can help the individual better manage their condition.

Is hoarding a mental illness or laziness?

Hoarding is not necessarily a sign of laziness, although it can often appear to be the case from an outside observer. Hoarding is actually a mental disorder that is characterized by an inability to discard possessions, regardless of their actual value.

The disorder is classified as a type of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) and is characterized by the compulsive acquisition of large amounts of possessions, which eventually clutter the person’s living space, making movement and normal activities difficult.

Hoarders often feel extremely attached to the items in their possession and may have difficulty letting them go or not responding to others’ requests to do so. Common triggers for hoarding include stress, anxiety, depression, and feelings of low self-worth.

Additionally, hoarding can often interfere with the person’s day to day functioning and ability to form relationships, as the disorder can sometimes become very isolating. In short, while hoarding may appear to be a sign of laziness, it is actually a serious mental illness that requires treatment and understanding.

What percentage of hoarders recover?

As the success rate of hoarders recovering varies greatly – depending on a variety of factors that include the severity of the hoarding problem, the hoarder’s level of motivation to change, the availability of resources, the quality of the treatment, and the age and health of the hoarder.

Studies have found recovery rates ranging from 30% to 80%, but such numbers should be taken with a grain of salt, as it is difficult to measure real recovery outcomes due to the nature of hoarding disorder.

Also, studies have failed to consider the costs and time associated with reclearcing a hoarded home.

Rather than a number, it is better to focus on the positive effects recovery can have. People who have recovered from hoarding disorder have reported feeling much happier, relieved, and less concerned about things being a certain way or perfection.

With treatment, many hoarders are able to give away items, calmly make decisions about possessions, and keep their living space safe and organized.

If you or someone you know is struggling with hoarding, it is important to reach out for help. Trained professionals who specialize in hoarding disorder can help create a plan of action, address the underlying causes of hoarding, and provide the necessary skills to achieve lasting recovery and freedom from compulsive hoarding.