The answer to who killed Lyanna Stark remains a mystery, though the popular theory within the A Song of Ice and Fire series centers around Rhaegar Targaryen, the son of the Mad King Aerys II Targaryen.
In the show, Lyanna dies in a place called the Tower of Joy, and is not seen alive again in the narrative. The Tower of Joy is a stronghold of House Targaryen, and is where Lyanna took refuge to escape an arranged marriage to Robert Baratheon.
Rhaegar gave chase to Lyanna and her father, Ned Stark, on the orders of his father, the Mad King, who then executed Lyanna’s father. It is thought that Rhaegar then killed Lyanna, either in his attempt to capture her or after the capture, as a result of her refusal to marry him.
Rhaegar had also kidnapped Lyanna’s older brother, Brandon, in anticipation of a forced marriage between Rhaegar and Lyanna, which is why Brandon was eventually killed. Though the actual death of Lyanna Stark is never revealed, this is the most popularly accepted theory.
Did Lyanna love Robert or Rhaegar?
The question of whether Lyanna Stark loved Robert Baratheon or Rhaegar Targaryen is one that has been debated by fans of George R. R. Martin’s “A Song of Ice and Fire” book series and its television adaptation, “Game of Thrones,” for years.
The truth of how Lyanna truly felt about Robert and Rhaegar likely lies somewhere in the grey between love, obligation, and familial duty.
Rhaegar was clearly infatuated with Lyanna, even going so far as to kidnap her and take her away to the Tower of Joy. While some might interpret this as a sign of love, others believe that Rhaegar’s actions were more rooted in duty and honor—he wanted to free Lyanna from her betrothal to Robert Baratheon and give her the opportunity to choose him as a suitor on her own terms.
Lyanna was a fiercely independent woman and was known to have a rebellious streak. She was also known to be fiercely loyal to her family and her beloved brother, Ned Stark. It is unclear if Lyanna felt anything for Rhaegar beyond a sense of respect and admiration for him as a leader and warrior.
Lyanna and Robert, however, did have a stronger relationship. Evidence suggests that the pair shared a passionate connection and were deeply devoted to each other. This is evidenced by their betrothal and Robert’s open grief when Lyanna died shortly after the two were married.
At the end of the day, the specific nature of Lyanna’s feelings towards either Robert or Rhaegar remain a mystery. Whatever her thoughts, it is clear that she had a great impact on both men and their actions would shape the world of Westeros for generations.
Why did Lyanna Stark fall in love with Rhaegar?
Lyanna Stark fell in love with Rhaegar because he was a handsome prince and charismatic leader, admired both in Westeros and beyond. His intelligence, compassion, and loyalty made him an ideal suitor, and his genuine romanticism and poetic nature spoke to Lyanna’s romantic heart.
As a spirited and independent woman, Lyanna and Rhaegar could have a conversations about many topics, and had a strong connection to one another. Rhaegar was attracted to her beauty, strength and courage, and Lyanna was drawn to his passion and enthusiasm.
Even though her father and oldest brother were opposed to their relationship, Lyanna and Rhaegar’s attraction to each other persisted. They were deeply in love, and their relationship was something that could not be denied.
While their relationship didn’t remain a secret for very long, it further confirmed that the two were in love. Lyanna eventually eloped with Rhaegar, and gave birth to their son, Aegon Targaryen, who would later become the infamous King of The Seven Kingdoms, Jon Snow.
The truth of why Lyanna Stark fell in love with Rhaegar will remain a mystery. However, it’s clear that they had an undeniable bond and an undeniable connection that would have been hard to ignore. One can imagine the emotions going through their hearts and the storybook love affair they must have shared.
It was a turbulent time in Westeros, and yet the beauty and strength of their love could not be broken.
Was King Robert in love with Lyanna Stark?
The truth about the relationship between King Robert Baratheon and Lyanna Stark is complicated and remains a mystery, even today. While Robert was certainly infatuated with Lyanna and professed his love for her multiple times, the exact nature of their relationship remains unclear.
Robert was betrothed to Lyanna’s older sister, Catelyn Tully, but when he heard of Lyanna’s abduction by Rhaegar Targaryen, he was determined to rescue her and determined to win her heart. At some point during their time in the Tower of Joy, Robert’s affections had turned to love.
However, Lyanna’s own feelings toward Robert remain unknown, as does the true nature of their relationship.
Robert would later enter a loveless political marriage to Cersei Lannister, and whether or not his feelings for Lyanna played a part in his ultimate decision is also not known. Lyanna died shortly after Robert’s rescue, leaving the Lannisters the secret of her true emotions, if any.
Given the grand scope of his ambition and the dangerous political climate at the time, it is highly likely that King Robert was too practical to let his love for Lyanna become an unwanted distraction.
In the end, we may never know if King Robert Baratheon and Lyanna Stark were truly in love. The riddle of what happened between them at the Tower of Joy continues to boggle fans of the series to this day.
What did Lyanna say about Robert?
Lyanna was known to have had a tumultuous relationship with her betrothed, Robert Baratheon. Unlike her brother and Robert’s close friend, Eddard Stark, Lyanna was not particularly fond of Robert. She had rejected many of his marriage proposals and was rumored to have called him abusive and “no dragon” due to his lack of strength and composure.
Despite her lack of amicable feelings for him, Lyanna ultimately agreed to marry Robert out of duty and to preserve the political alliance between their houses. Robert, however, had a great deal of love and admiration for Lyanna and she was known to have had a special fondness for him during the short period they were together before her untimely death.
Who did Robert Baratheon love?
Robert Baratheon, the former King of the Seven Kingdoms in the fictional TV series “Game of Thrones,” had an enduring love for his childhood sweetheart, Lyanna Stark. He met Lyanna while visiting her home in Winterfell as a young man, and the two instantly connected.
After Robert’s father arranged a betrothal with Cersei Lannister, Robert fell into a deep despair; this marriage would mean being separated from Lyanna forever. He continued to love Lyanna in secret even after she was abducted by Rhaegar Targaryen and was believed to have died.
Years later, when Robert led a rebellion against the Mad King, he believed that Lyanna was killed in the Tower of Joy. His grief was so deep that he even named his first-born son after her. In the end, Robert married Cersei out of obligation, never forgetting the love he had for Lyanna.
What did Lyanna whisper to Ned Stark?
No one knows for certain what Lyanna whispered to Ned Stark. It is a closely guarded secret that remains still unspoken. In the books, Bran Stark has a vision of the event that he interprests as his aunt whispering “Promise me, Ned”.
This has been a long held fan theory, as it is a moment that both Robert Baratheon and Ned take very seriously. There have been other wildly speculated speculation, such as Ned promising to protect Jon Snow as his own son, or even to protect the Targaryen line.
Ultimately, only those two people know what the true meaning behind that moment was and it will remain an everlasting mystery.
Did Ned know about Lyanna and Rhaegar?
No, Ned did not know about Lyanna and Rhaegar. According to the show and the books, Lyanna and Rhaegar were married in a secret ceremony, and Lyanna’s disappearance was kept secretive following the death of Brandon Stark.
Lyanna’s capture and subsequent marriage to Rhaegar was not shared with most people in Westeros at the time and Ned only found out the truth following the end of Robert’s Rebellion when the Targaryen’s were defeated.
It was at this point that Ned discovered Lyanna was married to Rhaegar and had a child with him.
Who was Robert Baratheon supposed to marry?
Robert Baratheon was supposed to marry Cersei Lannister, the twin sister of Jamie Lannister. Cersei was a beautiful and strong-willed woman from one of the wealthiest and most powerful families in Westeros.
She was seen as the perfect bride for Robert, and his father encouraged him to marry her.
The marriage would have brought together two of the most influential and powerful families in Westeros, in what promises to be a mutually beneficial relationship. Before Robert and Cersei could be married, however, Robert was betrothed to Lyanna Stark.
Lyanna was the daughter of Stark House, one of the most beloved Houses in all of Westeros. Robert and Lyanna’s love for each other was legendary and everyone in Westeros was in favor of their union.
Even though it was seen as an honor to be chosen as Robert’s bride, Cersei was devastated when she was told of the new betrothal. In the end, Robert was forced to marry Lyanna, which made Cersei very angry and resentful.
Despite this, their friendship remained strong throughout the rest of Robert’s life.
Who was Cersei supposed to marry after Robert?
Cersei Lannister was originally supposed to marry Crown Prince Rhaegar Targaryen after Robert Baratheon died. Rhaegar, son of the Mad King Aerys, was Aegon’s older brother and presumed rightful heir to the Iron Throne; however, he was killed during Robert’s Rebellion by Robert himself.
Robert instead married Cersei and took her into his household. Cersei, however, had already been promised to Rhaegar in a political marriage agreement before Robert’s victory. Had Robert not been victorious, Cersei would have been married to Rhaegar, probably crowning Rhaegar as the King of the Seven Kingdoms.
Cersei’s twin brother, Jaime, and Rhaegar were close friends and the two of them were said to have had some (presumably romantic) relationship before his death.
Did Cersei ever love Robert in the books?
The book of Cersei’s relationship with Robert is a complicated one and it’s not easy to say for certain whether or not she ever truly loved him. There are indications that the two had a very tumultuous relationship that was more based on mutual convenience than any kind of genuine love.
Cersei often thought of Robert as a fool and felt that she was constantly outmaneuvering him, which he himself sometimes acknowledged. Despite this, it is implied in the books that Cersei may have felt some attraction to Robert, and it may very well be that she felt love for him once in her life.
She says in the books, “Sometimes, very late at night, she would remember the way he had been when they first wed, when he was still Robert the Strong, Robert the Bull, before rage and wine had weakened him” This suggests that the two of them once had a strong connection and she still held some warm memories of him after all that had happened.
In the end, it might be impossible to fully answer this question without Cersei’s own thoughts, but it can certainly be said that she had complicated feelings for him.
Who is Jon Snow’s twin sister?
Jon Snow’s twin sister is named Lyanna Stark. She is also the biological sister of Ned Stark and a vent of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark. Lyanna was born at the start of Robert’s Rebellion, the war in which Robert Baratheon fought to claim the Iron Throne from the Targaryen dynasty.
Lyanna was betrothed to Robert Baratheon, who wanted to marry her in order to gain the allegiance of her father, Ned Stark. However, Lyanna ended up running away with Rhaegar, creating a scandal and inciting Robert to go to war with the Targaryens.
Upon Rhaegar’s death in the war, Lyanna died while giving birth to Jon Snow. Before her death, Lyanna made Ned Stark promise to keep Jon’s parentage a secret and raise Jon as if he was his own son. This was done in order to protect Jon from Robert Baratheon’s wrath.
Is the dragon queen Jon Snow’s sister?
No, Jon Snow is not the dragon queen’s sister. The dragon queen, otherwise known as Daenerys Targaryen, is Jon Snow’s aunt and is the daughter of his “father”, the late King Aerys Targaryen. Jon is actually the son of Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen, who is the older brother of Daenerys.
Although the two had never met until recently, they are related by blood and have a shared history as the last surviving members of House Targaryen.
Did Jon Snow have a twin?
No, Jon Snow did not have a twin. However, he was believed to be one of a set of twins due to a misconception. Lyanna Stark, his mother, had been married to Rhaegar Targaryen, who many believed had fathered a pair of twins with her.
One of these twins was believed to be Jon Snow, though in truth, he was only the son of Rhaegar and Lyanna. His true identity as the son of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark wasn’t revealed until later in his life, in the series.
He was raised as the bastard son of Ned Stark and given the surname ‘Snow’ for being born out of wedlock. Despite being believed to be one of a pair of twins early in his life, Jon Snow did not actually have a twin.
Is Valerie Targaryen in the show?
No, Valerie Targaryen is not in the show. To the best of our knowledge, she has never been included as a character in Game of Thrones, either in the books or in the television series. In fact, she is an original character created by a fan of the series, who imagines her as a secret daughter of Daenerys Targaryen and Jon Snow.
She has been featured in fan stories but does not exist within the canon of the show.
